These places have the best fish fry in Lake Geneva Wisconsin!
Ah, the beloved tradition of a Friday fish fry, a quintessential experience in the charming town of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. The issue is almost every Wisconsin restaurant has a fish fry, so how do you know which one to go to?
Since my family has been in the area since the 1930s I’ve rounded up all the best spots for an amazing Lake Geneva fish fry. You will be in the know and have a great time!
Top Places for Fish Fry in Lake Geneva Wi
Bonus Editions: All you can Eat Fish Fry at Duck Inn (Delavan)
This post is all about the best fish fry in Lake Geneva.
Foley’s Irish Woods
I have heard how good Foley’s fish fry was so was so glad I finally got to try it. And YES it does live up to all the hype! Foley’s has HADDOCK filets that are thick and juicy and the beer batter made for some of the best flavored fish fry I have every had. You get 3 massive pieces of fish, plus large wedges and fried granny smith apples. The restaurant was also an unexpected surprise. You walk through a bar when you enter, and then you see a beautiful yert like space with high wood covered ceiling. We will definably be back and I highly suggest!
- Experience: Foley’s is a cozy local spot known for turning Haddock fillets into golden masterpieces. The fish is marinated in Harp Lager, hand-battered, and delicately fried to perfection.
- Signature Dish: $14 gets you a plate of Haddock fillets served with fresh, thick-cut potatoes, fried Granny Smith apple slices with cinnamon and brown sugar, and your choice of malt vinegar or tangy tater sauce.
- When: Fridays from 5:00 PM to 10:00 PM.
- No reservations taken
Mars Resort
Mars is a local fav for a reason. Nestled right on the shore of Lake Como they offer the Wednesday and Friday fish fry from 11am to close and are busy most of that time. My favorite thing about this fish fry is you can mix and match the baked and fried pieces. I also love the fact you can get patato pancakes, fries or corn hush puppies with maple syrup đ Fair warning, go early if you don’t want a wait. I normally go for lunch since it is easy to get a table.
- Experience: A century-old dining gem offering rustic charm and stunning lake views. Mars Resort Supper Club is a local favorite for its delicious prime rib and seafood dishes.
- Signature Dish: The Fish Fry, available on Wednesdays and Fridays starting at 11am, features a choice of baked or fried cod, wild-caught walleye, lake perch, bluegill, or flounder.
- Price Range: $12 to $19 depending on the fish selection.
- Fair warning this place get PACKED especially during the warmer months so be prepared to wait. You can relax with a drink at their outdoor bar right on the beach. They even have boat rides and live music in the summer which I highly recommend.
- No reservations taken
Hawk’s View Golf Club
When you ask a local where they go for fish fry, this place keeps coming up! Hawk’s view has a great cod fish fry and again I love the sweet corn fritters with maple syrup. It was voted Favorite Fish Fry in Lake Geneva in 2023 so give it a try!
- Experience: Enjoy a fish fry at Hawk’s View Golf Club, where the simplicity of fresh Icelandic Cod takes center stage. You have the liberty to choose how you want your cod prepared â deep-fried, beer-battered, or baked.
- Signature Dish: The Friday Fish Fry is priced at $15.95, featuring fresh Atlantic Cod served with delightful sides like crispy potato pancakes, sweet corn fritters with maple syrup, or classic French fries.
- Award-Winning: Recognized as the “Favorite” Fish Fry in Lake Geneva in 2023.
- They DO take reservations which are recommended.
DJ’s in the Drink
- Experience: A casual lakefront haunt with a laid-back vibe, DJ’s in the Drink offers a range of American comfort food and a place locals keep coming back to.
- Signature Dish: The Friday Fish Fry includes cod, either baked or fried with their special beer batter. You can even mix it up with half and half. Also on the menu are fried shrimp, smelt dinners, fish sandwiches, and popular fish tacos.
- When: Served from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
- Come by car, golf cart, motorcycle or boat!
- No reservations taken
Pier 290
Is there anything Pier 290 can’t do?! This is my personal favorite restaurant of the area and their fish fry is the cherry on top. Elegant, tasty and great cocktails with an amazing lakeview….what more could you want.
- Experience: This upmarket American restaurant is right on the lake and offers a great fish fry experience and stunning lakeviews.
- Signature Dish: The Friday fish fry, available all day starting at 11:00 AM, includes 3 pieces of fish, a crisp potato pancake, applesauce, coleslaw, and tater sauce for $21.95.
- Atmosphere: With live music starting on Friday afternoon and a spectacular lake view, Pier 290 is a favorite for many Lake Geneva locals. They have a small outdoor “beach” with seats and firepits, a beautiful outdoor bar (that’s heated when cold), winter igloos to dine in, a great bar, gift shop and beautiful restaurant as well. It’s my personal favorite spot to be fish fry or not!
- The DO take reservations which are recommended.
Gracie’s Kitchen
While this place is new to the area it is making a name for itself with the fish fry. The restaurant building is very cute- it looks like a purple igloo and the fish fry was great. It is a casual atmosphere and I highly suggest.
- Experience: Located in an upmarket American restaurant right on the lake, Pier 290 offers an exquisite fish fry experience.
- Signature Dish: The Friday fish fry, available all day starting at 11:00 AM, includes 3 pieces of fish, a crisp potato pancake, applesauce, coleslaw, and tater sauce for $21.95.
- Atmosphere: With live music starting on Friday afternoon and a spectacular lake view, Pier 290 is a favorite for many Lake Geneva locals.
Bonus Edition: Duck Inn (Delavan, WI)
Steeped in history from the prohibition era, The Duck Inn was once a speakeasy, where patrons would discreetly “duck in” for a drink, whispering to “speak easy.” Now, it’s a place where history meets hearty meals.
- Friday Fish Fry Experience: Every Friday from 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM, The Duck Inn invites you to savor their fish fry delights. You have a variety of choices, from broiled or fried cod, all-you-can-eat smelt, mini-shrimp, to the delectable perch.
- All You Can Eat: For the fish enthusiasts, indulge in the all-you-can-eat options. Feast on endless broiled or fried cod for $20.00 or savor the sea with an unlimited supply of smelt for $22.00.
- Diverse Choices: If you’re in the mood for something different, they offer mini-shrimp at $17.00 or a generous serving of perch for $25.00.
- Kid-Friendly: The Duck Inn is also family-friendly with a special deal for the little ones at $12.00. Each kid’s meal comes with fries or potato pancakes, rye bread and butter, and your choice of applesauce or coleslaw.
- Historical Ambiance: Beyond the culinary delights, The Duck Inn offers an inviting atmosphere with casual fine dining in an elegant country setting. Immerse yourself in the historical duck theme, complemented by festive holiday decorations, a friendly and accommodating staff, and of course, fine food and cocktails.
These spots, each with its unique charm, promise not just a meal but an experience that captures the essence of this delightful lakeside town. Enjoy your fish fry exploration, and may your Fridays be filled with crispy delights!
This post was all about the best fish fry in Lake Geneva.
You may also like Best Pizza in Lake Geneva.
